New proposed ban on menthol cigarettes could be ‘huge landmark’ in reducing lung cancer deaths

May 11, 2022
A menthol cigarette ban will prevent lung cancer cases and deaths. Cigarette makers have deliberately marketed menthol cigarettes to Black people. Photo: Getty Images.
A menthol cigarette ban will prevent lung cancer cases and deaths. Cigarette makers have deliberately marketed menthol cigarettes to Black people. Photo: Getty Images.

A new proposed federal ban on menthol-flavored cigarettes would be a “huge landmark” in efforts to reduce cases of lung cancer in the U.S., especially among African Americans who have been targeted by the tobacco industry with menthol cigarette advertising for decades, according to lung cancer expert, Dr. Nina Thomas.

It could take more than a year for health experts from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to fully ban menthol cigarettes, but the decision is critical, said Thomas.

That’s because African American men are at the greatest risk in the U.S. for developing and dying from lung cancer, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). And for decades, cigarette manufacturers have deliberately marketed menthol cigarettes to Black people. Cigarette manufacturers advertised brands like “Kool” to African Americans as easier to inhale due to the cool sensation.

“This is a really big deal,” said Thomas, who is director of the lung cancer screening program at UCHealth University of Colorado Hospital.

“It’s the first time the FDA is really hitting the tobacco industry with limitations on what they’re able to sell. Not selling menthol cigarettes is the first step in limiting their market and how they can sell dangerous cigarettes to high-risk populations. This is going to improve mortality,” said Thomas. She is also an assistant professor of Medicine, Pulmonary Sciences and Critical Care at the University of Colorado School of Medicine on the Anschutz Medical Campus.

Do you want free help to quit smoking?

  • UCHealth offers free nicotine cessation programs.
  • Patients can get medications to assist them. These medications include nicotine replacement products like patches, gum, lozenges, inhalers and nasal sprays.
  • Cognitive counseling is also available.
  • How to get help?
    • Contact your primary care or specialty care provider to get a referral to speak with a tobacco treatment specialist.
    • Or call the patient lines. In the Denver area, call 720-553-0311. In southern Colorado, call 719-444-CARE (2273). In northern Colorado, call 970-224-5209 for the Health District of Northern Larimer County smoking cessation program.
    • Programs are free for patients.

Thomas said the proposed menthol ban marks the first time that health authorities have sought a major restriction in cigarette sales or manufacturing in over a decade.

The last major change came over a decade ago when cigarette manufacturers in the U.S. were forced to change their packaging to remove labels indicating “light” and “ultralight” cigarettes. Even so, people who smoke can still recognize their color labels and continue to buy preferred cigarettes, Thomas said. Like menthol cigarettes, so-called “light” cigarettes cause just as much illness and death as regular cigarettes.

If successful in banning menthol cigarettes, federal health authorities may soon impose additional restrictions, Thomas said.

“All cigarettes are dangerous. They increase your chances of developing and dying from lung cancer among many other diseases,” she said.

Death rates related to smoking are exceptionally high, according to the CDC. Every year, one in five deaths in the U.S. is tied to cigarette smoking, with about 480,000 people dying of illnesses tied to smoking. Of those who die from cigarettes every year, about 47,000 are African American.

Thomas said it’s vital to reduce the stigma surrounding smoking and for people who smoke to know that there are resources available to help them quit, get screened for lung cancer and get treatment for other smoking-related illnesses.

Cigarette manufacturers have deliberately targeted certain populations, promoting addiction to nicotine even to children and teens.

CDC information about cigarettes and the danger to Black men. A menthol cigarette ban could reduce lung cancer in at-risk populations.
CDC information about cigarettes and the danger to Black men. A menthol cigarette ban could reduce lung cancer in at-risk populations.

In recent years, vaping also has surged in popularity with manufacturers targeting children and teens with flavored vaping products. FDA experts also are considering restrictions on vaping products, but for now, the efforts to halt sales of menthol cigarettes will not restrict sales on flavored e-cigarettes.

Some studies link menthol cigarettes to an increased risk of certain types of lung cancer. These cancers may be related to the ease of inhaling the smoke from menthol-flavored cigarettes. It’s possible that menthol also encouraged people to smoke more frequently.

Thomas said banning menthol cigarettes is a great first step. Since she sees the direct impact of cigarette smoking in causing lung cancer, she’d love to see health officials ban the sale of all cigarettes.

About the author

Katie Kerwin McCrimmon is a proud Colorado native. She attended Colorado College, thanks to a merit scholarship from the Boettcher Foundation, and worked as a park ranger in Rocky Mountain National Park during summer breaks from college. She is also a storyteller. She loves getting to know UCHealth patients and providers and sharing their inspiring stories.

Katie spent years working as a journalist at the Rocky Mountain News and was a finalist with a team of reporters for the Pulitzer Prize for their coverage of a deadly wildfire in Glenwood Springs in 1994. Katie was the first reporter in the U.S. to track down and interview survivors of the tragic blaze, which left 14 firefighters dead.

She covered an array of beats over the years, including the environment, politics, education and criminal justice. She also loved covering stories in Congress and at the U.S. Supreme Court during a stint as the Rocky’s reporter in Washington, D.C.

Katie then worked as a reporter for an online health news site before joining the UCHealth team in 2017.

Katie and her husband Cyrus, a Pulitzer Prize-winning photographer, have three children. The family loves traveling together anywhere from Glacier National Park to Cuba.